I received an RFE that says: ‘You submitted publications, but there is no evidence of impact/citations.’ What should I respond?

The RFE message stating that ‘you submitted publications, but there is no evidence of impact/citations’ means that, although your portfolio of publications was considered, the immigration officer did not find clear evidence that these publications were widely recognized or influential in your field of expertise.

Situations like this are common in EB-1 cases, where it is essential to demonstrate that the academic or professional material disseminated had relevance and repercussion, such as being cited by other researchers, referenced in independent studies, or used as a basis for significant advances in the area.

To respond to this request, it is important to gather additional evidence that can prove the impact of your publications. For example, try to provide extracts from reliable databases such as Google Scholar, Scopus, or Web of Science, showing citation counts and, if possible, comments indicating international or national recognition of your contributions.

Additionally, including letters from experts who can attest to the influence of your publications in the academic or professional community may help strengthen the relevance of your work. Try to clearly demonstrate that your publications have been used by other professionals, caused impact, and served as references for further development in your field.

Remember that each case is unique and strict compliance with United States immigration laws is fundamental. Although this is a general example of how to organize your response, it is crucial that you remain attentive to the specific requirements of your process.

In situations like this, however, it is advisable to seek the analysis of specialists or companies specialized in the subject, avoiding scams or easy promises of guaranteed results. This response is provided with the intention of guiding you on how to proceed in organizing the documentation and drafting an adequate answer to the RFE.

Consulting a specialized professional can clarify specific doubts and help identify what type of evidence best complements your case without offering guarantees, always respecting the rules and legality of the United States immigration process.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.