I received an RFE asking me to explain why association X is selective and not just a dues-paying membership. What should I answer?

In an RFE of this kind within the EB-1 context, the goal is to demonstrate that your membership in association X depends on merit, not merely on paying dues. Your response must show that admission requires meeting real criteria, evaluated by people with recognized expertise in the field.

A good strategy is to organize the response into clear sections:

• Admission criteria: the objective requirements a candidate must meet, such as professional achievements, publications, or qualified recommendations.
• Selection process: how applications are reviewed, highlighting the committees or panels that assess merit.
• Benefits and recognition: the prestige of the association and what membership signals about your standing in the field.
• Supporting documentation: bylaws, regulations, official announcements, or official pages that confirm the rigor of the selection process.

The central point is to establish that the association grants recognition based on merit, not that anyone who pays can join. A clear, organized response backed by documents tends to be more persuasive.

Since each RFE is assessed individually, review carefully what the officer requested and, if possible, seek guidance from a specialist before filing your response.

About the author

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

As a journalist and lead editor at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps ensure that immigration topics are covered in a clear, trustworthy, and easy-to-understand way. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.