I joined a culinary association that requires 5 years of experience and a recommendation. Is it selective?

An association that only admits members upon proof of professional qualification and peer recommendation tends to be considered selective, and membership in organizations of this kind is one of the types of evidence that appear in EB-1 extraordinary ability cases. In your situation, requiring verified experience and recommendation letters to admit members already indicates that entry is not automatic.

It is worth understanding what gives this evidence weight. It is not enough for the association to be hard to join for any reason: what typically matters is whether the association requires outstanding achievements or accomplishments in the field, evaluated by recognized experts. A requirement for years of experience and references helps demonstrate selectivity, but the strength of the argument depends on how rigorous and recognized the organization is within the culinary world.

Some points that help assess the value of the membership:

• Whether admission depends on proven merit, and not merely on paying annual dues.
• Whether those who evaluate candidates are leading professionals in the field.
• Whether the association has recognition beyond the local level.

Keep in mind that no single piece of evidence determines the outcome. Selective membership is part of a broader set of evidence, analyzed case by case by the immigration authorities. Before building your case, it is worth checking the updated requirements on the USCIS website and evaluating your profile with a specialist.

About the author

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

As a journalist and lead editor at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps ensure that immigration topics are covered in a clear, trustworthy, and easy-to-understand way. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.