How to cite ‘judge of the work of others’ if I corrected master’s theses?

When preparing an application based on the EB-1 visa, one of the evaluated criteria is precisely your ability to act as a ‘judge of the work of others’ in your field of expertise. This practice requires that the candidate has been formally invited or assigned to review and evaluate the work of other professionals or researchers, which helps demonstrate recognition and leadership in the area.

In the case of having corrected master’s Theses (TCCs), it is important to analyze exactly what role you played in this activity. If the correction was limited to pedagogical support and guidance of a specific group of students without a formal peer review process or without being part of a recognized evaluation committee or body, it may be difficult to classify this activity as ‘judge of the work of others’ within the EB-1 requirements context.

On the other hand, if you were officially invited, based on your expertise, to carry out a critical and specialized evaluation of the Theses – in a manner comparable to peer review or with participation in academic evaluation committees – there are arguments to describe this role as a professional judging function.

It is essential to demonstrate that this activity had relevance in the academic community or industry, with documentation proving your official participation, formal invitation communications, and the critical and comparative nature of the evaluation. Robust documentation may include invitation letters, criteria used in the evaluation, opinions, or publications related to your role in this function.

Finally, it is always essential to remember the importance of following United States immigration laws, as well as seeking information from specialized and trustworthy professionals in the field to guide every detail of the process. This way, you avoid falling into traps of miracle promises or inconsistent information that could harm the progress of your application.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.