Participating in curriculum evaluation committees at universities counts as ‘judge’?

The EB-1 visa, intended for individuals with extraordinary abilities, requires proof of achievements that demonstrate significant recognition in the field of expertise, including activities such as acting as a judge, evaluator, or member of committees that review the work of other professionals. In the context of participating in curriculum evaluation committees at universities, this activity may be considered a ‘judge’ function, provided it is demonstrated that the committee is indeed responsible for analyzing and weighing the quality of peer work and curricula in a rigorous manner with national or international recognition.

The key factor is to evidence that your participation occurred within a structure where your judgment was relevant to the selection or evaluation of professionals or research, contributing to the advancement of the field. If the evaluation committee has a restricted or local role, without the same weight or recognition, it may be more difficult to fit this experience into the criterion required by EB-1.

It is important to remember that each case is analyzed individually and the evidence submitted must demonstrate the relevance and impact of your role. Thus, keeping detailed documentation – such as invitation letters, descriptions of the performed functions, publications, or other records that prove the importance of the committee – can help support your argument in the EB-1 process.

I emphasize the importance of strictly following United States immigration laws, always seeking specialized guidance and proceeding cautiously to avoid falling into misleading offers or marketing campaigns that promise guaranteed results. Each situation is unique and an individualized analysis is essential to understand how your activities may fit the criteria required by the EB-1 visa.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.