I received an RFE asking ‘explain why association X is selective and not just a paid membership.’ What should I answer?

In EB-1 visa petitions, it is common for the immigration officer to request details demonstrating the selective nature of associations and recognitions.

When answering an RFE requesting an explanation of why association X is selective and not merely a membership club, it is essential to show that membership involves rigorous criteria beyond just the payment of a fee.

The response should include: (1) Admission Criteria – clear requirements such as professional achievements, publications, and important recommendations; (2) Selection Process – description of committees or panels that review applications; (3) Benefits and Recognition – highlighting exclusive advantages and the association’s prestige; (4) Supporting Documentation – regulations, notices, or official information that confirm the rigor of the selection.

This justification must be clear and well-founded to demonstrate that the association grants recognition based on merit.

Finally, it is recommended to strictly follow immigration laws and seek professional guidance to ensure an adequate response and avoid fraud or unfounded promises.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.