I hold the position of ‘Editor-in-Chief’ of a student magazine. Is this considered a judge?

When we discuss the EB-1 visa, especially the part related to extraordinary achievements, it is important to understand that the categories require proof of recognition and outstanding contribution in your field. One of the evaluated criteria may be performing duties that involve judging the work of other professionals, that is, acting as a ‘judge’ (evaluator or jury member, for example).

In your case, the position of Editor-in-Chief of a student magazine typically involves leading the editorial team, selecting and reviewing content, as well as ensuring the quality of the publication. These activities, although they demonstrate leadership skills and academic or professional competence, do not directly fit the definition of ‘judge’ provided for some of the EB-1 criteria.

Generally, for a role to be considered as acting as a judge in this context, it is expected that the person performs official evaluator functions or active participation in expert panels that regularly contribute to the analysis and recognition of peers’ work at events, publications, or international competitions.

It is essential to consider that each case may have specific nuances and that the interpretation of the EB-1 criteria may vary according to the understanding of the authorities responsible for analyzing United States immigration applications.

Thus, if there are doubts or the need to better guide how to demonstrate your credentials and performed functions, it is always advisable to seek guidance from specialized sources or professionals in the immigration area, as well as to stay attentive to official regulations. This helps avoid misunderstandings, frauds, or campaigns that promise miraculous results and, most importantly, ensures that immigration laws are being properly followed.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.