At the final merits stage, USCIS says I ‘just checked the boxes’. What should I do?

It is important to start by understanding that the term ‘just checked the boxes’ used by USCIS may indicate that, although you have submitted evidence that meets the formal requirements of each criterion individually, they did not robustly demonstrate the extraordinary ability required by the EB-1 visa. This comment usually points to the need for a more integrated and convincing argument about your relevance and impact in your field of expertise.

To respond to this evaluation, a first step is to carefully review all the documentation already submitted. Try to identify if there are strong points that could be better explored or integrated to show a cohesive narrative about your career and achievements. For example, you can highlight how your publications, awards, contributions, citations, or invitations to prominent events interrelate, creating a panorama that goes beyond the ‘checklist’ and actually proves that you are a standout professional at the national or international level.

Another consideration is that when USCIS makes such observations, it may be appropriate to explore the possibility of submitting additional evidence or even requesting a reconsideration or reopening of the case, if there is a basis for such action. It is essential in this process to act in compliance with United States immigration laws.

Therefore, it is recommended to seek the support of recognized immigration experts who understand well the nuances of visa categories and can help put together a strong response to the final merits analysis. Lastly, it is wise to be wary of offers that promise miraculous results and marketing campaigns not based on solid legal foundations. The authenticity and consistency of your documents, as well as how they are presented, are key to the USCIS evaluation.

Always aim to use reliable means and follow official guidelines, ensuring that your response or petition aligns with the country’s legal requirements. Remember that each case has its particularities and it is essential to proceed with caution and responsibility to avoid future setbacks.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.