I participated as a jury member for a final thesis project at a renowned university. Is it considered judge?

When analyzing the profile for an EB-1 visa in the United States, it is common to observe whether the candidate has relevant contributions in their field of expertise, including participation as a reviewer (or “judge”) of other professionals’ work. This criterion can include roles in evaluation panels for publications, participation in selection committees for events or awards, among other activities that demonstrate recognition of their expertise.

Specifically, having participated as a jury member for a final thesis project at a renowned university can indeed be considered a form of acting as a “judge” of others’ work, but there are some points to consider. Generally, for this activity to be valued in the EB-1 context, factors such as the prestige of the institution, the relevance and scope of the evaluated works, as well as the consistency and frequency of this participation, are analyzed.

A one-time or internal participation may not have the same impact as an established position in internationally recognized evaluation committees. It is essential to keep in mind that the evaluation for EB-1 is made based on a robust collection of evidence that proves the candidate’s excellence and relevance of contributions in their field.

Thus, relying solely on an isolated experience may not be enough. Many factors will be analyzed, so it is important to gather detailed documentation, such as recommendation letters, publications highlighting your participation, and, if possible, evidence that your work had a significant impact in the field.

Always remember the importance of strictly following United States immigration laws and seeking information from reliable sources. It is advisable to consult specialists in the area, avoiding miracle promises or approaches that guarantee results without a complete analysis of your profile. Each case is unique, and an individualized evaluation will help identify which evidence is most appropriate when applying for the EB-1 visa.

This answer is for informational purposes and aims to help better understand how certain types of activities, such as participation in evaluation boards, can be interpreted within the United States immigration context.

Victoria Harper

Editor-in-Chief

Meet the author

Leading journalism and editorial content at Visto n’ Visa, Victoria helps make immigration topics clear, trustworthy, and easy to understand. Her focus is on delivering useful, human, and relevant content for people exploring new paths abroad.